For years, the cruise industry has been locked in an epic battle of “bigger is better.” Carnival Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean have seemingly tried to outdo each other by building cruise ships so massive that they could double as floating cities. But now, the tides might be turning—both cruise lines are dropping hints that they’re considering something their loyal passengers have been clamoring for: smaller cruise ships.
Let’s dive into why this shift might be happening and what it means for the future of cruising. Spoiler alert: it’s not just about squeezing through smaller ports (though that’s part of it).
The Era of Mega-Ships: How Did We Get Here?
Once upon a time, cruise ships were built to sail to exotic ports, offering passengers an experience that blended adventure with luxury. Over the years, however, cruise lines decided to make the ship itself the main attraction.
Take Carnival’s Excel-class ships, for instance. They’re packed with jaw-dropping features like Bolt, the first roller coaster at sea. Not to be outdone, Royal Caribbean’s Icon of the Seas, crowned the world’s largest cruise ship, boasts an indoor Aquadome, water parks, and enough entertainment options to make Vegas jealous.
But there’s a catch: these floating behemoths aren’t exactly nimble. With lengths over 1,000 feet and capacities nearing 7,600 passengers, they’re too large to dock at many ports. So, while they offer more activities than you could possibly do in a week, they’ve also lost some of the intimacy and exclusivity that many cruisers cherish.
Cue the clamoring for smaller ships.
Why Passengers Want Smaller Ships
Big ships have undeniable perks, but they’re not for everyone. Here’s why cruisers are asking for a return to more modestly sized vessels:
- Access to Unique Ports
Smaller ships can go where their hulking counterparts can’t. Imagine docking at a secluded Mediterranean village instead of a busy industrial port. - Deeper Connections
On mega-ships, it’s easy to feel like just another face in the crowd. Smaller ships offer more opportunities to bond with the crew and fellow passengers, creating a sense of community. - Fewer Crowds
Let’s be real—no one loves waiting in line for a poolside margarita or a turn on the water slide. Smaller ships mean fewer people vying for the same amenities. - Old-School Charm
Many seasoned cruisers have fond memories of sailing on smaller ships that prioritized classic elegance over flashy attractions.
Carnival and Royal Caribbean Drop Hints
So, are Carnival and Royal Caribbean finally listening? It seems like it.
Royal Caribbean’s “Project Discovery”
Royal Caribbean hasn’t officially announced plans for a smaller class of ships, but it’s not exactly a secret either. CEO Michael Bayley teased the possibility during a 2023 voyage on Allure of the Seas, saying, “We have a lot of conceptual work going on.”
More recently, he confirmed the company is working on a new class of ships. While details are scarce, Bayley’s cryptic Facebook post—calling the initiative a “journey”—suggests Royal Caribbean is serious about stepping away from its supersized reputation.
Carnival’s Facebook Tease
Carnival’s approach has been subtler, but equally telling. Brand ambassador John Heald recently asked his Facebook followers if they’d like to see a new, smaller ship akin to the company’s Spirit-class vessels.
The response was overwhelming. Thousands of fans chimed in, with most shouting a resounding “YES!” Some waxed poetic about their love for the Spirit-class ships, which debuted in 2001 and remain fan favorites despite their smaller size.
While Carnival hasn’t confirmed anything official, Heald’s post strongly suggests that the company is at least considering it.
What Smaller Ships Could Mean for the Industry
If Carnival and Royal Caribbean do launch smaller ships, it could signal a significant shift in the cruise industry. Here’s what to watch for:
- Boutique Experiences: Smaller ships could allow cruise lines to offer more specialized itineraries, like wine tours in Bordeaux or wildlife cruises in Alaska.
- Luxury Without the Price Tag: Compact ships often feel more luxurious, but that doesn’t mean they have to come with a luxury price. Carnival and Royal Caribbean could bridge the gap between affordability and exclusivity.
- Less Is More: With fewer onboard distractions, passengers might reconnect with the joy of simply sailing and exploring new places.
Are Smaller Ships the Future?
While it’s too early to declare a full-scale industry pivot, the signs are there. Carnival and Royal Caribbean seem to be waking up to the fact that not every cruiser wants a water park and zipline at sea. Sometimes, less truly is more—especially when it comes to capturing the romance and adventure of ocean travel.
For now, we’ll just have to wait and see whether these hints turn into actual blueprints. But one thing is clear: cruise fans are ready to embrace the smaller ship trend with open arms—and maybe a piña colada or two.
So, what do you think? Ready to swap mega-ships for more intimate adventures? Let us know in the comments!
Leave a Reply